"We were listening to Tim Burton's 'Nightmare Before Christmas' as we were getting Lucy ready, and her makeup really embodies those vibes," says makeup artist Jo Baker, who created the whole look using CoverGirl products.
Baker layered lashes with a healthy coating of the brand's Exhibitionist Mascara, $6.59, adding extra drama with the help of the Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Black Onyx, $6.59, which she used to paint on stylized undereye lashes.
She kept the rest of the look simple, perfecting Boynton's complexion with the TruBlend Undercover Concealer, $7.99, also creating a subtle contour and flush with the TruBlend Serving Sculpt Contour Palette in Bloom Babe, $9.99. Last but not least, she added a delicate frosty lip, using the Exhibitionist Metallic Lipstick in Can't Stop, $7.99.
SEE NEXT PAGE: Look of the Day: Lucy Hale's Classic on a Budget