I've found mine and the other editors have their picks too. But some of you haven't found "the one," and that makes me want to cry. Nothing opens your eyes up or gives you a polished look like a great mascara (except maybe these tips). Are you still looking for the perfect mascara? Check out this advice from TotalBeauty.com readers and start searching for your mascara match here.

"Diorshow is the best I have ever used. I've recommended it to a bunch of people, and everyone has loved it." -- AllieB

"I like Neutrogena Healthy Volume (my holy grail), Max Factor 2000, CoverGirl Thick Lash, Maybelline Full 'n' Soft." -- HaileyCosmic

"I have found a mascara that I am in LOVE with!!! It called Two-Timer by The Balm, which is sold on Sephora.com and at some Sephora stores. It makes my lashes thick and dramatic without clumping, flaking, or smudging! I often get asked if I'm wearing falsies!" -- edie_faye

• Still haven't found "the one"? Try one of these.

• Just don't try one of these. TotalBeauty.com readers couldn't stand 'em.

• Make any mascara look better with these tips.