TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 5.1*
Grand Offense: Too weak. "It is definitely not the liner for oily skin or warm weather. It smudges all over the place. I wish it had better staying power." -- cheapthrills, TotalBeauty.com member
"The liner is very soft and malleable so the tip of the pencil is prone to breaking. (You can lose a lot of product this way!)" -- janedoe, TotalBeauty.com member
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 3.5*
Grand Offense: Messy packaging. "I really dislike this container/application bottle. You pull out the wand and the stuff goes everywhere ... then the wand has a really blunt foam applicator that creates serious fall-out upon application. The actual kohl powder is really lovely. I just wish it wasn't in this type of bottle." -- venus_nouveau, TotalBeauty.com member
According to your reviews, these eyeliners -- some of which had
potential to be great -- possessed at least one fatal flaw that was
undetectable at the store. Read on to find out which product harbored your
biggest pet peeve. (Spot one of your favorites? Write a counter review to
boost its rating!)
