Average TotalBeauty.com user rating: 4.4*
Grand offense: Looks oily on hair
What you said: "It made my [fine, permed] hair limp, wet and greasy-looking. Tried it different ways for a few days. Very disappointed. Not worth the money. I returned it." -- MaureenC, TotalBeauty.com member
Average TotalBeauty.com user rating: 5.7*
Grand offense: Just okay
What you said: "I have fine, limp hair and this product does not work for me at all. [My hair looked] stiff and clumpy." -- MsSassy1225, TotalBeauty.com member
Average TotalBeauty.com user rating: 3.4*
Grand offense: Falls flat
What you said: "It adds a little volume but after a few hours it goes flat. Maybe it's because it makes my [very thin and oily hair] kinda sticky and oily. By the end of the day my head feels like I haven't washed it for a week." -- Mila, TotalBeauty.com member
Average TotalBeauty.com user rating: 2.3*
Grand offense: Unpleasant finish
What you said: "I tried this in conjunction with the shampoo, conditioner and thickening spray [and] it left my hair stiff and tangled. [I] returned it promptly." -- meg61299, TotalBeauty.com member
We depend on good volumizing products to transform flat, fine hair into a voluptuous mane of full, soft strands. But sadly, not every product does the job right (or leaves enough wiggle room for human error). Find out which duds left these flat-haired gals feeling deflated.