"Use a makeup removing wipe (one that's good for even waterproof formulas), and follow with a gentle cleanser to rinse off the residue. (I prefer unscented gentle cleansers like Dove Sensitive Skin Beauty Bar, $2.99)," advises Nazarian. "Pat skin dry, and apply a lightweight calming oil-free moisturizer (Cetaphil or Cerave lotion is a good option)."