Editors' Pick Winner: Nudestix Eyebrow Stylus Pencil & Gel
Why: This double-sided tool transforms the wimpiest of brows into a bold look that Cara D. would be proud of. The precise, supercreamy pencil applies like a dream, and the clear gel has amazing hold that keeps brows in place all day.

Honorable Mention: Glossier Boy Brow

Readers' Choice Winner: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Why: I have tried everything, but nothing looked nearly as natural or as defined as what the Brow Wiz has done for me. My brows have honestly never looked better. Perfect brows that last all day and don't wash off if you sweat or get wet.

Honorable Mention: Benefit Instant Brow Pencil

Editors' Pick Winner: Sonia Kashuk Undercover Liquid Concealer
Why: A lightweight concealer that packs major undereye-bag coverage. The creamy formula blends easily into skin and helps you fake a full night's sleep in seconds.

Honorable Mention: Lorac Porefection Concealer

Readers' Choice Winner: It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Anti-Aging Concealer
Why: This is an amazing under-eye concealer. A little goes a long way. It spreads easily and does not feel heavy at all. It lasts all day without creasing or settling into any fine lines.

Honorable Mention: BareMinerals Concealer Broad Spectrum SPF 20

Editors' Pick Winner: Giorgio Armani Eye Tint
Why: The liquid formula of this eye shadow allows you to have complete control over the application -- pile on more for an intense look, or blend it out for an easy daytime look. It dries quickly and stays put, even on oily lids.

Honorable Mention: Wander Beauty Exquisite Eye Liquid Shadow

Readers' Choice Winner: Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Shadow
Why: This is a creamy-gel texture, which is easy to work with. The color is true and really stays put -- it stayed in place a good 18 hours before I removed my makeup. There was no creasing or caking whatsoever.

Honorable Mention: Make Up For Ever Artist Shadow

Editors' Pick Winner: Stila Got Inked Cushion Eye Liner
Why: You'll never go back to your basic liquid liner after this. Dip your brush (or Stila's La Quill Precision Eye Liner Brush) onto the cushion-sponge to saturate it with bold color, then apply. The lightweight, smudge-proof formula makes it easy to create a variety of looks.

Honorable Mention: NYX Vivid Brights Liner

Readers' Choice Winner: Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
Why: I keep coming back to this eyeliner for many reasons: The color payoff is awesome, it's very long-lasting and it doesn't smudge. The first time I tried it, it applied so much better than a pencil liner. I was able to get it so close to my lash line, and the brush helped me create a precise and bold look.

Honorable Mention: Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Editors' Pick Winner: Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Foundation
Why: Say goodbye to FaceTune and get ready to tag all your photos #nofilter. This lightweight-yet-full-coverage foundation looks just as amazing IRL as it does in photos, and the comfortable formula lasts all day. With 40 shades to choose from, you're sure to find a perfect match.

Honorable Mention: L'Oréal Paris True Match Lumi Cushion Foundation

Readers' Choice Winner: CoverGirl Outlast Stay Fabulous 3-in-1 Foundation
Why: I normally have to wear concealer to cover my acne, but not with this product. It also has great staying power. Usually my foundation is coming off by the end of the day, but this lasts all day. It really does work like a primer, too, and the SPF is a bonus.

Honorable Mention: BareMinerals Original Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 15