I have this pencil in the shade Amethyst. I don't want to use it because I never want to run out of it! It's probably the creamiest eyeliner I've ever encountered. It's perfect, absolutely perfect for a smudged smokey eye. Fabulous for the water line too.

I have a hard time blending the pearl liner on my lid. It's great that the color is prominent. Maybe I need to play with it more.

The kajal liner glided so smoothly along my waterline, and unlike some deceptive ones that glide easy with no color deposit, this one had a decent color pay off in one stroke. No tugging or scratching along the waterline. One thing is though that it isn't very long-wearing along the waterline, at least not for me. I use a trick where I first sweep a Q-tip lightly along the waterline to absorb the excess water, since my eyes tend to be more watery. Immediately after that, I apply the kajal liner and it stays put fairly well. Since this liner is so pigmented while being soft, I have also used this for smudging on the eyelid when creating a green smokey eye. It works very well for that as well. I would recommend using a primer on the lid before the eye makeup though since this has the potential to smudge more than you'd like throughout the day.

I LIKE THIS EYELINER PRODUCT AND I USE IT ALONE OR WITH OTHER EYELINERS--DEPENDING ON THE LOOK I AM GOING FOR AND ALSO THE COLORS I NEED TO GO AFTER THE "LOOK" I WANT TO ACHIEVE..MIX AND MATCH COLORS AND LINERS AND YOU MIGHT BE SURPRISED AT WHAT TURNS OUT...I KNOW I WAS THE FEW FIRST TIMES NOT ONLY THAT, A LOT OF OTHERS NOTICED (in a good way) AND PEOPLE KEPT COMING UP TO ME ASKING "HOW DID YOU CREATE THAT EYE LOOK" INSTEAD OF GOING INTO DETAIL EACH AND EVERY TIME...ALL I DID WAS WINK AND SMILE AND MOVE ON--LEAVING THEN WITH A ? AND SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT....JUST A WINK AND A SMILE...AND MOVE ON!!!!

Pros- Super pigmented, great variety of colors, soft. Cons- TOO soft (the tip has broken off more than once), smudges beyond belief, messy, and creases after only a few hours of wear (even WITH a primer). I have this in three colors, as I got them on a clearance 1/2 price deal. Even paying $9 for the product, I still felt that I overpaid. This stuff winds up getting everywhere on my lid, my fingers, and even the sink! I want a liner that will give me a neat clean line, and this just doesn't deliver.