Tarte Skinny smolderEYES Amazonian Clay Waterproof Eyeliner by Tarte, Eyeliner Review

9

Best liner so far...

I have very oily lids and oddly shaped eyes/lids so I'm always trying new liners, hoping to find something that will stay on and won't transfer to my upper lids/crease by the end (or middle, for some pencils) of the day. So far, this is the best one I have tried and I think I'm going to buy it in some more colors, it's THAT good. I currently have it in slate, which is a nice, dark grey. Maybe even...read more a little darker than I was going for, but I'd rather the grey be too dark than too light. This liner is highly pigmented and very, very soft. I need only the lightest touch to my lids to get a solid color payoff and a very nice, even line. This is both refreshing and a bit of an adjustment after months of using waxy, under-pigmented colors that require a heavier touch and/or drawing over the same line 3 or 4 times to get enough color. The first day I wore it, the liner didn't transfer or crease AT ALL. I was amazed. Since then, it has both transferred and creased, but not nearly to the degree that other liners do on me. I still have a line left at the end of the day! At the top and bottom, in fact, which is amazing since I also tend to rub my eyes a little more than I should. I have not yet worn this liner when putting in eye drops, so I'm not sure how well it delivers on the promise to be waterproof, but if it can stand up to my oily lids, I have high confidence! There is no glitter in this liner nor is it flaky at all, so it doesn't irritate my eyes when I'm wearing contact lenses. This is my new favorite liner and I can't wait to buy it in purple and brown! I wish they also made it in navy, but I might try out one of the green shades.

tallredamanda | 434 reviews

This review is: Helpful | Not helpful | Inappropriate | 0 of 0 people said helpful