9 Clean Eyeliners to Suit Every Makeup Look

Gone are the days when natural eyeliners lasted about two seconds. Over the last few years, there's been a lot of innovation in the clean eyeliner category. So now you can find plenty of formulas that are safe, nontoxic and actually stay put. Whether you prefer pencil, gel or liquid, there's a clean eyeliner for everyone.

We rounded up our favorite clean eyeliners to help you create both subtle and dramatic makeup looks. Don't forget to finish things off with a clean mascara.

Image via Imaxtree