Why it's great: "This is the best eye makeup remover out there -- not greasy, not oily and doesn't sting," says one user. "I have used this product for years after trying many others and I always go back to it. I will make a special trip to the mall just for it." Our readers note that the key to using this gentle makeup remover is to hold the soaked cotton ball to your eye for a few seconds before swiping away your remaining eye makeup.
Why it's great: Shaking the bottle activates the bi-phase formula of this Lancôme makeup remover. Our readers say it takes off even the heaviest makeup. "It removes waterproof mascara, glitter liner, heavily applied smoky eyes — you name it, no problem," says a reviewer. If you're balking at the price tag, readers assure that a little goes a long way.
Why it's great: Readers with sensitive eyes love the gentle formula of this Clinique makeup remover. "I have very sensitive eyes that will turn beet red ... so I have to be very careful," says one reader. "This remover is so gentle that it's never given me [any] trouble and it takes off every last fleck of eye makeup."
Why it's great: Readers love that this fragrance-free product doesn't contain irritating ingredients. "A lot of makeup removers are either too harsh (drying) or too oily," says a user. "But this one [balances] getting rid of makeup and not stripping away oils."
Why it's great: The word "oil" can make breakout-prone women run in the other direction, but M.A.C.'s Cleanse Off Oil is friendly to all skin types. "I wasn't sure if this would be for me since I have super oily skin, but ... there is literally no makeup left on my face after using this product," raves one reviewer. "And it doesn't break me out.... Oily-skinned gals, don't be shy!"
As total product junkies, we tend to spend a lot of time putting stuff on our faces. So at the end of the day, a good makeup remover is just as important as the makeup we're taking off.
When choosing which makeup remover is best, we always look for three main characteristics: It takes off everything in one swoop, it won't clog pores and won't leave gross, oily residue on our beloved pillowcases (so not good for the complexion). And it appears that TotalBeauty.com readers feel the same. They chose these 20 eye makeup removers, micellar waters, cleansing waters and makeup-removing wipes as the best of the best for everything from removing raccoon eyes to keeping skin fresh and clean.
