TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.7* Why it's great: This "thick and creamy" eye treatment is a favorite among reviewers because it "is rich and goes on smoothly." The refreshing "cooling sensation" it delivers is another perk. "All I need is a small amount and it makes my under eye skin soft, smooth and glowy," sums up one reader.
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.7* Why it's great: "I swear that after using this product for a week people asked me what I was doing differently," raves one reviewer, who writes that she "can't live without this." Other readers express similar feelings, saying it "smoothes the delicate eye area and has a very light tint that brightens and blends well." As one reviewer summarizes: It "helps with fine lines, puffiness and dark circles, plus SPF. What more could you ask for?"
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.8* Why it's great: True to its name, this cream is "remarkably, wonderfully potent," according to reviewers. This moisturizer is "made to brighten the eye area and fade dark circles ... [it] means what it says and says what it means," writes one satisfied reviewer. "This is unbelievable," writes another. "It is really rich and creamy, and a little goes a long way."
Why it's great: The raves are in: Our readers agree that this nifty eye cream makes the "skin under [their] eyes look amazing." One reviewer calls it great for "plumping fine lines," while another even lent her jar to her mom, who "noticed a huge difference."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.9* Why it's great: Readers say this "intense eye repair cream" has a "great anti-aging formula" that is "very high-quality" and "pretty amazing." It "reduces lines," helps with "puffiness and dark circles" and "keeps skin fresh, hydrated and supple." One reviewer is impressed that the cream is "not too heavy" or greasy, which means she can "apply eye makeup over it in the morning without the makeup smudging."
If you're one of the many women who think eye creams are just another way for the cosmetic industry to get you to buy more skin care products, dermatologist Kenneth Beer, MD, PA, says you should reconsider. The skin around your eye is the thinnest layer of skin on your entire body, and therefore the most sensitive, he says. So using a cream made specifically for your eyes is crucial, especially as you age.
"Eye creams can, and often do, show results if they are used appropriately and for a long enough time," says Beer. The trick is to find the best eye cream for your skin's needs. If you feel like you've been duped by the hundreds of eye creams on the market promising to erase your dark circles, puffiness and fine lines, you probably haven't tried the ones on this reader-approved list. Our reviewers have tested all the potions, creams, and elixirs for the delicate eye area and boiled it down to these 16 eye creams that actually work — and we've even added in a few editor's picks too. Ready to become an eye cream believer?
