Figuring out what eye makeup to wear is one of our biggest daily morning decisions (along with deciding whether it's a dark roast or an espresso day). Do we want a daring swipe of purple eyeliner or a sexy black cat eye? Regardless of the look we choose, we need the best eyeliners, from the perfect smudgy kohl to a precise, smudge-proof liquid liner, to get the job done.
Unfortunately, we too often have days when we realize 20 minutes after an important meeting or date that the fabulous liner we applied is running down our faces. Smudged and smeared (in a bad way) eyes are a beauty disaster that needs to be avoided at all costs — but how much are you willing to spend for a great liner that doesn't budge? Some cost upwards of $58. If we had $58 we wouldn't give it to a pencil, no matter the pigmented brilliance.
So, can we get a great eyeliner without breaking the bank? According to our Total Beauty reviewers, the answer is yes. We've compiled their favorite gel, liquid, pencil, pen and waterproof eyeliners that cost less than $10. These cheap eyeliners don't smudge or disappear, but they also are easily removed with eye makeup remover. Our reviewers say the results from these drugstore liners are comparable to, if not better than, the leading department store brands. So, what are you waiting for? It's time to say goodbye to smudged raccoon eyes and having to reapply at noon, and hello to these eyeliners that are colorful, cheap and long lasting.
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.1*
Why it's great: "This little liner is a powerhouse," gushes one reader. "Its felt tip is easy to use, and it's long-lasting and smudge proof." Others agree, saying the felt tip eyeliner makes creating a cat eye a breeze, and the drugstore eyeliner won't flake on you throughout the day. "The color really lasts and it blends well with pencil liner," one user says. "People always ask me how I get my make up so perfect [when I use this eyeliner]."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.2*
Why it's great: If you're looking for lasting power, readers recommend this product. "It stays on all day," they promise. "The black pearl [shade] makes my hazel eyes pop like crazy," one reader adds. Other perks? The application is "supereasy," and the "color doesn't flake or fade."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.2*
Why it's great: This eyeliner claims to give you lasting drama -- and according to users, it follows through. "[It] stays on all day with no smudges or runs!" raves one user.
Reader after reader gushes over the product's staying power and creamy formula. "I have a hard time finding a good eyeliner that doesn't smudge or smear from my lower lash line," another user writes. "This doesn't budge until you decide to wash it off."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.2*
Why it's great: Readers say this eye liner is "perfect for a smoky eye" due to its "smooth application," and creates a "bold and pigmented" eye look. Users also say the eye liner doesn't budge throughout the day and it provides better definition than a kohl. "You never have to sharpen it, and the blender tip works great too," says one reader. "It's one of my favorites!"
Figuring out what eye makeup to wear is one of our biggest daily morning decisions (along with deciding whether it's a dark roast or an espresso day). Do we want a daring swipe of purple eyeliner or a sexy black cat eye? Regardless of the look we choose, we need the best eyeliners, from the perfect smudgy kohl to a precise, smudge-proof liquid liner, to get the job done.
Unfortunately, we too often have days when we realize 20 minutes after an important meeting or date that the fabulous liner we applied is running down our faces. Smudged and smeared (in a bad way) eyes are a beauty disaster that needs to be avoided at all costs — but how much are you willing to spend for a great liner that doesn't budge? Some cost upwards of $58. If we had $58 we wouldn't give it to a pencil, no matter the pigmented brilliance.
So, can we get a great eyeliner without breaking the bank? According to our Total Beauty reviewers, the answer is yes. We've compiled their favorite gel, liquid, pencil, pen and waterproof eyeliners that cost less than $10. These cheap eyeliners don't smudge or disappear, but they also are easily removed with eye makeup remover. Our reviewers say the results from these drugstore liners are comparable to, if not better than, the leading department store brands. So, what are you waiting for? It's time to say goodbye to smudged raccoon eyes and having to reapply at noon, and hello to these eyeliners that are colorful, cheap and long lasting.
