This updo is not one of Underwood's best, but at least it knows what it wants to be. It's fussy and overwrought, but it beats out Simpson's run-to-the-convenience-store look. Half Updo Winner: Underwood.
Photo 12/15
Loose Waves: Carrie Underwood
A big, sexy head of waves looks great on Underwood. Lots and lots of hair cascading everywhere is just what a country music star calls for.
Photo 13/15
Loose Waves: Jessica Simpson
Jessica Simpson is the reigning queen of sexy waves. She wrote the book. She set the standard. She broke the mold ... well, you get the idea. There's no beating the queen at her own game. Loose Waves Winner: Simpson.
Photo 14/15
Wearable Look: Jessica Simpson
What about a real look that real women can wear, not just for special occasions, but every day? Women love Jessica Simpson's bob, it's easy to style, versatile and a flattering line.
Photo 15/15
Wearable Look: Carrie Underwood
This long straight hairstyle is about the closest Carrie Underwood comes to presenting a look that real women can take for themselves and wear every day. But its styling and length require more time in front of the mirror and touchups throughout the day. Wearable Look Winner: Jessica Simpson. Overall Champion: Jessica Simpson.
The similarities between these two fair-haired songbirds is striking (beyond boy-toy choices). Whether you're on Team Jess or Team Carrie (or you're cheering for both), it's clear they're both style icons in their own right. But which diva takes the crown in a direct faceoff? Let's find out ...
