Photo 5/18

Best Brows

Editors' Pick Winner: Lime Crime Bushy Brow Gel

Why: Looking for a new brow pomade? This mousse-y formula quickly coats brows for a natural yet groomed look. We also love the cuter-than-cute packaging.

Readers' Choice Winner: Benefit Brow Contour Pro

Why: The kitsch factor is definitely there with this four-color clicky pen, but it's also a damn good product. The shades are top-notch, as is the pigmented, easy-to-blend formula.

Photo 6/18

Best Concealer

Editors' Pick Winner: First Aid Beauty Hello FAB Bendy Avocado Concealer

Why: "Bendy" sounds about right: This concealer offers great coverage with a breathable formula that won't crease or cling to any dry patches.

Readers' Choice Winner: Too Faced Born This Way Super Coverage Concealer

Why: This concealer feels light as a feather — which is even more impressive when you realize how top-notch the coverage is.

Photo 7/18

Best Eye Shadow

Editors' Pick Winner: Jill Stuart Beauty Jelly Eye Color

Why: We're suckers for sparkles and this jelly-textured eyeshadow majorly delivers on that front. Get ready for eyelids that shine like the stars!

Readers' Choice Winner: Milani Metallic Lights Pearl Liquid Eyeshadow

Why: Want to kick your eyeshadow game up a notch? This pearly liquid eyeshadow looks amazing layered over other colors (and equally amazing worn alone). It's sparkly enough to earn you compliments while still being subtle enough for the office.

Photo 8/18

Best Eyeliner

Editors' Pick Winner: Pat McGrath Labs Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner

Why: It can be tough to nail that perfect cat eye — but not with this genius liner. The precision tip is super easy to control and the ultra-black formula glides right on (and lasts all day).

Readers' Choice Winner: Fenty Beauty Flyliner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner

Why: This gorgeous liner handily lives up to its name: It's the deepest black with a slight satin-y shine and wears through pretty much everything (even tears). Plus, it makes drawing Rihanna-worthy cat eyes a snap.

Photo 9/18

Best Foundation

Editors' Pick Winner: VDL Perfecting Last Foundation SPF 30 PA++

Why: This hardworking foundation is basically perfect skin in a bottle: The coverage evens out your complexion and the finish looks oh-so natural. Bonus: It's SPF 30!

Readers' Choice Winner: Laura Mercier Flawless Lumiere Foundation Radiance Perfecting

Why: Light as air with a gorgeous, skin-like finish, you'll find yourself falling hard and fast for this winning foundation.