Why you should skip it: It's easy to see why this DIY treatment is all over Pinterest -- pimples have a tendency to pop up at the most inconvenient time, with no spot treatment readily available. According to Fusco, though, using toothpaste to dry up a pimple overnight is nothing but a myth.

Nearly every dermatologist we spoke to said toothpaste as a pimple treatment is one of the worst things you can do to your skin. It dries the skin around the pimple, not the actual pimple, says dermatologist Jeannette Graf, MD, Assistant Clinical Professor of Dermatology at Mount Sinai Medical Center in New York. "Some varieties of toothpaste can be caustic, and overnight contact can burn skin," adds Fusco. Meaning: Your pimple is going to be a whole lot angrier and inflamed than it already was.

What you should do instead: For those painful, below-the-surface blemishes, resist the urge to squeeze them. Instead, ice them. Graf says this will help constrict the pimple (and ease the throbbing pain.) You can also apply 1 percent hydrocortisone cream to a surprise pimple -- Graf says it's the closest thing to an in-office cortisone shot (which can magically erase cystic acne) as you can get.

Why you should skip it: There's many a coffee grounds face scrub on Pinterest, claiming antioxidant- and glowy-skin benefits. First off, know that because the coffee beans are roasted, the antioxidant benefits are much less, according to Macrene Alexiades-Armenakas, MD, PhD, FAAD and founder of 37 Actives. Plus, she says the abrasive nature of coffee grounds is not something many people's faces will tolerate or benefit from; coffee grounds are too harsh, and cause micro-cuts in the skin. These micro-tears present as irritation, and can even harbor breakout-inducing bacteria. Not exactly the radiant skin you had in mind when you decided to re-purpose this morning's coffee beans.

What you should do instead: If you love the feeling of a physical exfoliant scrubbing away your dead skin cells, Fusco says a better option is to add finely ground sugar to your cleanser -- it melts as you use it, making it a gentler option. It's also a natural source of glycolic acid.

Why you should skip it: Even though baking soda may feel gentler than a physical scrub thanks to its fine texture, it can be extremely irritating to the skin, cautions Goldfaden. Blame its alkaline nature. The surface of your skin should be slightly acidic --typically 4.5-5 on the pH scale -- to protect against pollutants. When the pH of your skin's moisture barrier is disrupted, dryness and breakouts follow.

What you should do instead: Peredo recommends whipping up a mask of papaya and pineapple. Papaya contains a natural alpha-hydroxy acid and pineapple contains exfoliating enzymes; together, they gently resurface the skin with little to no irritation.

Why you should skip it: While apple cider vinegar isn't going to melt your face off "Raiders of the Lost Ark" style, it will upset the pH level of your skin, says Graf. And although Peredo concedes that apple cider vinegar does inhibit yeast and bacteria, it can be extremely drying, making it a less-than-ideal option for attaining the skin of your dreams.

What you should do instead: "Witch hazel has natural astringent and anti-bacterial properties, making it ideal to treat acne or oily-prone skin," says Peredo. It's a much gentler -- and more effective -- natural alternative to ACV.

If you worship at the altar of ACV (or that's all you have in your cabinet), be sure to dilute it with two parts water before applying to your face, says Goldfaden.

Why you should skip it: Spoiler alert: The cat eye tape hack is doing more than helping you achieve the perfect winged look -- it's prematurely aging your skin.

"Too much tugging on and around the eye region can cause loose and sagging skin," says Goldfaden. Plus, stretching your skin causes mini tears and breakdown of elastin and collagen. Since the eye area has no sebaceous glands, and is made up of the thinnest skin on the body, it's the first to show signs of aging, Graf adds. In other words, you want to be extra gentle to it.

What you should do instead: Graf recommends a plastic ruler, or essentially any other flexible object that won't stick to your skin.