Stila's Lip Glaze gave us the supernaturally shiny (if slightly sticky) lips we all desired in the '90s. The biggest downside: We had to be careful not to disturb study hall with the clicking noise that accompanied cranking out more gloss.
Photo 4/26
No. 23: Butterfly Hair Clips
...Because who didn't want to look like she had a family of plastic butterflies nesting on her head?
Photo 5/26
No. 22: Gap Perfume
If one could turn the exhilaration of first crushes and school dances into a fragrance, we're pretty sure it would smell just like Gap's Heaven or Dream.
Photo 6/26
No. 21: Clear Mascara
Clear mascara is to beauty what Clear Pepsi was to soda: thrilling for a hot second, but ultimately kind of pointless.
Photo 7/26
No. 20: Jane Cosmetics
Brightly colored makeup that we could afford on even the most meager allowance? Sign us up. (Even better, Jane recently made a comeback.)
