Why it's great: "Each compact comes with four perfectly coordinated matte and shiner shades, made to work together and complement each other," raves one reviewer about this palette. "I was highly impressed at the silky, satiny texture of Revlon's shadows." Others agree, saying these shadows are "incredibly long-lasting with great color options" and "are very pigmented."
Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Revlon ColorStay 16-Hour Eyeshadow here.
Buy Now on Amazon
*At time of publication
Photo 3/11
Best Drugstore Eye Shadow No. 9: Physicians Formula Baked Collection Wet/Dry Eye Shadow, $7.95
Why it's great: Readers love that these shadows can be applied wet or dry, allowing them to achieve many different looks. "You get three highly-pigmented shadows that can be used wet (for a more intense look) or dry (for a much softer look)," explains one reviewer. "They are beautiful, blendable and last ... no creasing or smudging after hours of wear," adds another.
Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Physicians Formula Baked Collection Wet/Dry Eye Shadow here.
Buy Now on Amazon
*At time of publication
Why it's great: If there's one thing our readers can't get enough of, it's this shadow's "beautiful shades and shimmer." They claim the long-lasting eye shadow "makes eyes pop," and you're guaranteed compliments while wearing it. "The colors go on extremely well, and are heavily pigmented," says one reader. "They have great color payoff, not to mention the 30 color choices." Others agree, saying while the small container can be off-putting, the "well-priced, nicely packaged and good quality eye shadow" is worth it.
Agree? Disagree? Write your review for NYX Loose Pearl Eye Shadow here.
Buy Now on Amazon
*At time of publication
Photo 5/11
Best Drugstore Eye Shadow No. 7: L'Oréal Paris Studio Secrets Professional Eye Shadow Singles, $4.48
Why it's great: Color pay-off and a variety of shades and finishes were this drugstore eye shadow's big selling points, according to readers. "There are so many different colors to choose from, and they have great pigmentation." Others agree, adding that the eye shadow "performs splendidly" with minimal fallout and lasts on even the oiliest of complexions. "These colors truly last all day and are superblendable," says one user. "I love them."
Agree? Disagree? Write your review for L'Oréal Paris Studio Secrets Professional Eye Shadow Singles here.
Buy Now on Amazon
*At time of publication
Photo 6/11
Best Drugstore Eye Shadow No. 6: Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner Eye Candy Collection, $11.95
Why it's great: Readers say this eye shadow's star quality is its ability to blend well and enhance any eye color. "You can purchase sets catered to your specific eye color, and they're pigmented and affordable," comments one user. Others agree, saying the "long-lasting" shadows are easy to blend and layer, which allows for a variety of day-to-night looks. "I love all of the colors, and they look so pretty," gushes one reader. "They last and compliment your skin beautifully."
Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner Eye Candy Collection here.
Buy Now on Amazon
*At time of publication