TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.6*
Why it's great: Color pay-off and a variety of shades and finishes were this drugstore eye shadow's big selling points, according to readers. "There are so many different colors to choose from, and they have great pigmentation." Others agree, adding that the eye shadow "performs splendidly" with minimal fallout and lasts on even the oiliest of complexions. "These colors truly last all day and are superblendable," says one user. "I love them."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for L'Oréal Paris Studio Secrets Professional Eye Shadow Singles here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.7*
Why it's great: Readers say this eye shadow's star quality is its ability to blend well and enhance any eye color. "You can purchase sets catered to your specific eye color, and they're pigmented and affordable," comments one user. Others agree, saying the "long-lasting" shadows are easy to blend and layer, which allows for a variety of day-to-night looks. "I love all of the colors, and they look so pretty," gushes one reader. "They last and compliment your skin beautifully."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Shadow & Liner Eye Candy Collection here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.8*
Why it's great: "The colors are spectacular," raves one reviewer. Others agree, saying they "blend fantastically and are very pigmented." One fan loves "how easy it is to apply and blend these eye shadows" and added that they "last very long."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for L'Oréal Paris Hip High Intensity Pigments Bright Shadow Duo here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.0*
Why it's great: If you struggle with mastering a perfect eye shadow application, then readers you'll love this eye shadow's labeled colors, according to readers who say they are "great for beginners."

"The colors are all very pigmented, and even without primer, they stand out magnificently," gushes one reader. "These shades also have a good staying power, as I can go all day without any of the colors creasing." Others agree, saying this eye shadow is easy to apply and is comparable to prestigious brands. "A lot went into this palette, and the price is incredible," says one user. "I have gotten so many compliments wearing it."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Collection here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.0*
Why it's great: Readers say this eye shadow is "sublime" for its "highly pigmented and intense color" at such a reasonable price. They claim the waterproof stay power is so "amazing," it doesn't need an eye shadow primer to keep the shadow from creasing or losing pigment. "It lasts forever, and I mean forever," gushes one reader. "I wore this shadow for 48 hours, and the color didn't budge -- even with all my dancing, mountain climbing and a shower. Amazing."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Eye Shadow here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication