TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.0*
Why it's great: Readers say this eye shadow is "sublime" for its "highly pigmented and intense color" at such a reasonable price. They claim the waterproof stay power is so "amazing," it doesn't need an eye shadow primer to keep the shadow from creasing or losing pigment. "It lasts forever, and I mean forever," gushes one reader. "I wore this shadow for 48 hours, and the color didn't budge -- even with all my dancing, mountain climbing and a shower. Amazing."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Eye Shadow here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.3*
Why it's great: This "fabulous product" is a must-have for reviewers. "Nothing [adds] radiance to my eyes like this eyelightener," says one reviewer. Another adds that after using this eye shadow, her "eyes look wider and brighter." One happy reviewer adds, "This makes my eyes pop."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Physicians Formula Multi-Colored Eyelighter here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.3*
Why it's great: This under-one-dollar shadow is the best drugstore eye shadow, according to reviewers. "Wet n Wild has created some truly creative, fun, sexy colors," says one reader. "The shadow doesn't crease nor budge — and it's great for my budget." Others wholeheartedly agree, adding that the shadows have "amazing pigmentation" and "a little goes a long way."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Wet n Wild Color Icon Eye Shadow Single Eyeshadow here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication