TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.1*
Why it's great: Readers say this drugstore lipstick "is by far the longest lasting lipstick they have ever used," and it "outperforms pricier [brands]." Users also say Rimmel's 16-hour formula doesn't dry out lips and wears flawlessly for 12 hours after application. "The staying power of this lipstick is insane," writes one user. "It seriously lives up to its claims and looks fresh all day."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Rimmel London Provocalips 16HR Kissproof Lip Colour here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.4*
Why it's great: This drugstore lipstick provides "rich, yet sheer pigmentation," as well as "unrivaled moisture," according to readers. "It makes my desert-dwelling, chapped lips smooth, relatively shiny and incredibly comfortable," says one user. "I've never had a product that provided such great moisture." Others agree, noting the lip product has "amazing" stay power and a "sweet" smell. "This is one of the best products I've tried in a long time," gushes a reviewer. "It's easy to apply, comes in natural but noticeable colors and eliminates the need for lip balm. I highly recommend giving it a shot."

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Neutrogena MoistureSmooth Color Stick here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.5*
Why it's great: "I will be going back for more, because I need more lipsticks like this in my life," exclaims one reviewer. "They glide on smooth and creamy and feel comfortable." Other readers chime in, adding that the bold line is full of "awesome colors" that are "very wearable," despite being, as the name suggests, vividly colorful.

Agree? Disagree? Write your review for Maybelline New York Color Sensational Vivids Lip Color here.

Buy Now on Amazon

*At time of publication