Shiseido's shimmery cream shadows are so, so pretty — and as apidae92 puts it, "they never dry out" (even after six years). She also points out that they're quite versatile and long-lasting: "I use it as a primer but it's beautiful alone."
Though it comes in an unassuming simple red tube, this foundation has quite the cult following."Living in a place with dry winters, it's a perfect winter foundation," notes Reddit user 2catsinjapan. She also notes that it wears well with wrinkles and that it "looks good in photos."
We'd pick this mascara up for the adorable packaging alone, but it turns out the formula's nothing to sneeze at either: "This keeps my lashes curled and volumized all day long," says Reddit user cheesedoggo.
