When it comes to deeper skin tones, Stiles recommends bronze and copper tones that will "melt into the skin," noting that you should keep a special eye out for "shades that read more red than orange," which are especially flattering. She also warns that certain pearly highlighters -- and even certain gold tones -- can read ashy. For her part, Inglessis says that rose gold works especially well on warmer and deeper skin tones.