The pigmentation and shine of Burt's Bees Lip Oil, $9, are incredibly muted, so it's perfect for a subtle, no-makeup makeup look. Like Burt's Bees best-selling lip balms, the formula contains a touch of beeswax for staying power, but you'd never know it by the lip oil's insanely smooth, liquid texture. Meadowfoam seed oil, coconut oil and shea butter keep your lips feeling soft and plump for hours.

Missha Essential Lip Oil in Honey, $12, looks, feels and smells like you should be squeezing it out of a plastic bear. It's made with avocado oil and honey extract, the latter of which may account for why it seems to stick to lips for hours on end. We're even bigger fans of the rose-tinted Berry, which tastes like raspberry bubble gum and provides the perfect popsicle-stain flush of color.

Lip oil tints feel amazing and give great, subtle color, but the pigment's usually gone by the time you've polished off a can of La Croix. The tint in Milk Makeup Oil Lip Stain, $18, sticks around through eating and drinking, and moisturizes with black currant oil, olive oil and vitamin E. We love the shade Feelz, a punchy color that wakes up any complexion, and the rollerball applicator -- it gives us serious Lip Smacker Lip Gloss vibes.

The addictive quality of Yes to Miracle Oil Primrose Lip Oil is probably due to its gorgeous fragrance -- like an expensive rose perfume, which is pretty impressive when you consider this product costs just $5. The oil's pale-pink tint boosts lips' natural color without looking like makeup, and ingredients like evening primrose oil, shea butter, cocoa butter and castor seed oil give the product a lush, emollient texture. But TBH, that incredible scent is why we're going to hoard a tube in every handbag.

There's not a whole lot about our high-school makeup routine that makes us nostalgic, but we've still got a thing for Lancome Juicy Tubes. So color us surprised when we found a tinted gloss that we love even more than Juicy Tubes: Lancome Juicy Shaker Pigment Infused Bi-Phased Lip Oil, $22. The oil's fat, cone-shaped cushion applicator means you can apply it in a flash, and there are 25 lovely shades to try -- each with its own, irresistible flavor. We haven't found one we don't lick -- er, like.