Photo 5/9
For That "Week in St. Kitts" Post-Vacation Glow
Estee Lauder Bronze Goddess Powder Bronzer in Light, $36
Rimmel London Natural Bronzer in Sun Dance, $4.99
The Breakdown:
In a single swipe, I can tell whether a bronzer has any of my three deal breakers: It's too brown, too orange, or has too much shimmer. With that "I've just returned from the islands" natural summery glow, both of these bronzers passed all three tests. The products lasted on my face all day without breaking into splotchy patches, and both have just the slightest amount of glimmer to warm up the complexion.
The Winner:
It's a tie. The tortoiseshell packaging on the Estee Lauder product is so pretty I leave it out on my vanity to display, but the Rimmel product is comparable for a fraction of the price.
Photo 6/9
To Hide Your Sleepless Nights
YSL Touché Éclat Concealer in Luminous Radiance, $40
The Body Shop Lightening Touch Concealer in 04, $14.50
The Breakdown:
Concealer is concealer, said no one, ever -- which explains why, even with its $40 price tag, one YSL Touché Éclat concealer is sold every ten seconds. Its ability to make dark circles and fine lines disappear has made Touché Éclat a "Holy Grail" product. My favorite shade, Luminous Radiance, is best for fair skin with slight pink undertones to it.
The closest match in The Body Shop concealer dupe is 04, which is more shimmery and lilac-based (similar in color to Benefit High Beam). The lighter shades of both concealers wake up my tired eyes and make my whole face seem more awake. But the shimmery Body Shop concealer calls attention to the lightness beneath my eyes and sinks into my fine lines, rather than camouflaging them.
The Winner:
YSL Touché Éclat Concealer in Luminous Radiance
Photo 7/9
The Powder That Stops Oil in Its Tracks
Make Up For Ever HD Pressed Powder, $22
Essence All About Matt! Fixing Compact Powder, $3.99
The Breakdown:
Make Up For Ever HD Pressed Powder is a midday godsend for my oily T-zone. Applied as the last step in my makeup routine, my face stays shine-free for a solid eight hours. The white powder is so fine and translucent, it doesn't dull the color of my blush, bronzer or foundation the slightest bit. Essence All About Matt fixing powder also temporarily stops shine, but I have to keep applying it to my oily spots throughout the day. (And, because it doesn't include a mirror, I'm forced to casually use my webcam to apply it.). The drugstore dupe also loses points for appearing slightly white on top of my makeup, enough to lead me to touch up my muted blush before the day is over.
The Winner:
Make Up For Ever HD Pressed Powder
Photo 8/9
Your Stay-Put Makeup Solution
Smashbox Photo Finish Primer, $36
NYX Studio Perfect Photo-Loving Primer, $13
The Breakdown:
We hear about the "blurring effect" in makeup everywhere these days. Blur creams, blurring primers ... you name it. If we're not using high-definition makeup, we're blurring. Smashbox's Iconic Photo Finish Foundation Primer was one of the first "blurring" products on the market, and its smooth finish that fills in pores and makes makeup look seamless is truly extraordinary. But as much as I love the Smashbox formula, after taking a look at the ingredients in NYX's primer, I found the two products are nearly identical. The NYX primer also kept my makeup in place all day long, didn't leave a greasy feeling and blurred the pores in my trouble areas. Both are winners, but NYX is a clear bargain with equal results.
The Winner:
NYX Studio Perfect Photo-Loving Primer
Photo 9/9
The Eyeliner That's as Easy as Tracing
Lancôme Artliner Liquid Eyeliner Pen, $30
L'Oreal Paris Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, $8.95
The Breakdown:
Liquid eyeliner is one of my "desert island beauty essentials," so I'm picky when it comes to a regular for my makeup bag. These two liquid eyeliners glide on easily and have slightly harder tips than other products I've tried, which makes drawing a steady line easier. The Lancôme product has more of a spongy tip, whereas the L'Oreal eyeliner is like a fine point pen. Although I like the results of both eyeliners, I run out of product on the tip of the Lancôme liner partway through applying. I often have to shake it up or dip the applicator deeper into the tub multiple times to get product on the brush.
The Winner:
L'Oreal Paris Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner
You fall head over heels for a $58 BB cream that leaves your skin soft, dewy and impossibly clear -- and you're quite sure there's no other product in the world that will make you look so youthful and radiant. So you do want any beauty-product-obsessed girl on a budget would do: splurge on another bottle and eat ramen for the next week. No matter how much you love a product, it can be hard to justify the price tag, especially on day six of shrink-wrapped noodles. While there truly are some magical beauty products out there for which there is no substitute, plenty of expensive department store beauty products have a drugstore doppelganger that works just as well -- and for a lot less money. We road-tested every popular beauty dupe on the market to find out which high-end beauty products are worth the splurge and which ones you may want to reconsider.
