Evolve Gentle Cleansing Melt has a thick, gooey texture that rinses off easily without leaving a greasy film. It's 100 percent organic, vegan and natural -- no harsh preservatives here. Natural sugars rinse away makeup and help dry skin feel hydrated and soft. Bonus: it smells warm and cozy, like vanilla.

The Body Shop Nutriganics Softening Cleansing Gel is like a magic eraser for makeup, but a word of caution if you have sensitive eyes: The blend of fragrances, though they smell pretty, can be a bit irritating. The babassu oil used in the formula comes from the nuts of the babassu palm tree in Brazil, and the aloe hails from central Guatemala. Both are community fair trade and organic. They're also the reason why makeup practically slides off of skin, which stays calm and moisturized.