"The bottle says to 'compare to Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover,' so that's what I did. And I have to say, they really are similar. The Up & Up formula is a little thinner liquid, so you may notice it sliding down your face as you apply, but it took off my mascara and liner just as well as my usual Neutrogena -- for $2 less a bottle." -- Sarah Carrillo, Senior Editor
"I can't imagine why anyone would pay three or four times the price for a makeup wipe that performs like Target's less-expensive house brand. These wipes have the same look, smell, and feel as Pond's Clean Sweep Towelettes, $4.69. Diehard fans of Pond's might notice a slight difference in the quality of the towelette (Up & Up's is not as plush), but for something that literally gets wiped across your face and tossed in the garbage in about 13 seconds flat, I'm willing to make that barely-noticeable sacrifice. But I will say this: Up & Up's packaging needs help -- as soon as the "re-sealable" adhesive flap over the opening gets rubbed with enough makeup remover, it never re-seals again. (A problem I cured by storing the package in a zip-top bag, so the towelettes don't dry out.)" -- Colleen Rush, Executive Editor
"If I'd applied this in a dark room, I would've sworn it was the old standby I always use -- Coppertone Sport Continuous Spray. Same beachy smell, same quick-absorbing formula that dries to a clean finish. But instead of a 6 oz. Coppertone can, with Up & Up I get 10 oz.-worth of product for the same price. After a long day at the Santa Monica beach last weekend, I reapplied every 90 minutes and didn't get a lick of burn. I'll be buying this for sure." -- Beth Mayall, Editor in Chief
"The Ulta lipstick in Red Carpet Red is vibrant and richly pigmented -- a perfect fire-engine red hue. The lipstick comes in dozens more shades, from delicate blush tones to deep raspberries, all of which I'm eager to try. The product has a nice, creamy application, and doesn't flake or dry out lips. At just $8 a pop, they're a steal. I also love how tiny and compact the lipstick tube is -- fits nicely inside a small clutch or the front pocket of your jeans." -- Amanda Montell, Editorial Intern
"This hand cream is fantastic! I actually get excited to use this in public (except when everyone gets a whiff of the invigorating scent and asks to snag a few squirts of it). It has shea and macadamia nut butter so it really moisturizes my hands and keeps them soft for hours at a time. I'll be carrying this in my purse at all times." -- Tiffanie Petett, Assistant Editor
