Best Highlighter/Contour
Editors' Pick Winner: Physicians Formula Rosé All Day Set & Glow
Why: This versatile powder can be used as a glowy face powder or a subtle highlight — plus, it comes with a dewy balm. It's perfect for creating a natural, lit-from-within glow.
Readers' Choice Winner: Tower 28 SuperDew Highlighter Balm
Why: Formulated with ingredients such as aloe vera and green tea extract, you can trust this clear balm to dewify your skin, inside and out.
Best Lip Balm
Editors' Pick Winner: Brush on Block Protective Lip Oil SPF 32
Why: Who knew lip sunscreen could be so gorgeous? Available in three different shades, this tinted lip oil moisturizes, protects and, best of all, prettifies your pout.
Readers' Choice Winner: Bite Beauty Agave+ Intensive Lip Mask
Why: This occlusive lip treatment is about as protective and hydrating as they come. It'll rehab even the driest lips in no time!
Best Lip Gloss
Editors' Pick Winner: Bobbi Brown Crushed Oil-Infused Gloss
Why: In a lot of ways, this is the perfect lip gloss: It's super shiny and pigmented, it's non-sticky and perhaps most importantly, it's very hydrating. Who even needs lipstick and/or balm when you've got a gloss this good?
Readers' Choice Winner: Em Cosmetics True Gloss
Why: Each shade in this line up is so decadent and saturated (well, except for the clear gloss of course, which we also love). We're falling hard and fast for Michelle Phan's revamped brand!
Best Lipstick
Editors' Pick Winner: Maybelline New York Super Stay Ink Crayon Lipstick, Matte Longwear Lipstick Makeup
Why: Is this lipstick magic? Somehow, it manages to stick around for hours and hours on end, without leaving lips dry. And the finish and color selection are great, too!
Readers' Choice Winner: E.L.F. SRSLY Satin Lipstick
Why: Can you believe that this lipstick is only $3? It glides evenly onto lips with great coverage and pigmentation. Another bonus? It wears well in the long haul.
Best Mascara
Editors' Pick Winner: It Cosmetics Lash Blowout Volumizing Mascara
Why: First of all, we love the fact that this mascara looks like a round barrel blow out brush. But beyond the packaging, it's perfect for creating long, voluminous lashes that a) look real and b) feel comfy.
Readers' Choice Winner: Maybelline New York The Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara Eye Makeup
Why: You can't really go wrong with a Maybelline mascara — and this one is particularly great. It delivers excellent length and volume, and we love how fluffy the brush is.
