Best Eye Shadow
Editors' Pick Winner: Dominique Cosmetics Latte 2 Palette
Why: We love how this palette balances wearable neutrals with fun pops of color. And trust, these shadows are buttery-smooth, with great color payoff!
Readers' Choice Winner: E.L.F. Liquid Glitter Eyeshadow
Why: There's nothing like a good glittery top coat eyeshadow — especially when it's as sparkly (and wallet-friendly) as this one.
Best Eyeliner
Editors' Pick Winner: UZ by Flowfushi Eye Opening Liner
Why: Between its easy-to-wield brush tip and the absolute rainbow of colors to choose from, this liquid liner has become a fast favorite.
Readers' Choice Winner: Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup-Proof Liquid Eyeliner
Why: It's not every day that you find a liquid liner that a) sticks around all day, b) creates foolproof wings and c) costs roughly the same amount as a cup of coffee. This is what dreams are made of!
Best Foundation
Editors' Pick Winner: Kevyn Aucoin Foundation Balm
Why: A little goes a long way! Just the teensiest dab is enough to cover your complexion, leaving you with skin so seemingly perfect you can't quite believe it.
Readers' Choice Winner: Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Foundation
Why: Thanks to its full coverage finish, this foundation does indeed leave your skin looking airbrushed and flawless. No filter needed!
Best Highlighter/Contour
Editors' Pick Winner: Physicians Formula Rosé All Day Set & Glow
Why: This versatile powder can be used as a glowy face powder or a subtle highlight — plus, it comes with a dewy balm. It's perfect for creating a natural, lit-from-within glow.
Readers' Choice Winner: Tower 28 SuperDew Highlighter Balm
Why: Formulated with ingredients such as aloe vera and green tea extract, you can trust this clear balm to dewify your skin, inside and out.
Best Lip Balm
Editors' Pick Winner: Brush on Block Protective Lip Oil SPF 32
Why: Who knew lip sunscreen could be so gorgeous? Available in three different shades, this tinted lip oil moisturizes, protects and, best of all, prettifies your pout.
Readers' Choice Winner: Bite Beauty Agave+ Intensive Lip Mask
Why: This occlusive lip treatment is about as protective and hydrating as they come. It'll rehab even the driest lips in no time!
