My takeaway from this little experiment is that while yes, I do still favor BTS for daily use, Damn Girl gives you even more bang for your buck. (I chalk the smudging up to my oily skin, paired with this specific formula.)
It's nice to have options: BTS is great for a dramatic everyday mascara and Damn Girl is great for va-va-voom volume that is perfect for special occasions. So if you're looking to ditch the false lashes and try something easy peasy to get some dramatic lashes, definitely give Damn Girl a whirl.