What Actually Happened: After waking up with a full face of makeup, my skin was as greasy as a slice of pizza. Every one of my pores felt clogged. It was like my face was being suffocated. While I could easily go 72 hours without washing my face when I wasn't wearing any makeup, I just couldn't do it now. I caved and used Lumene Lahde Micellar Cleansing Water to take off my foundation and eye makeup every morning (except for the very last day of this experiment, which I'll get to later). Ah, sweet, sweet relief. My skin could finally breathe -- until I applied my makeup all over again, that is.

What an Expert Said Could Happen: Washing your face before working out is a whole lot more important than doing it afterwards, says Schultz. Think about it: Anything that's gotten onto your skin up until that point (like makeup, dirt, debris, and air pollution, to name a few) can be pushed into your skin if you wipe your face dry with a towel, explains Schultz.

"Most people don't pat their face dry -- they wipe their face dry, pushing that crap into their pores," he says. Now, if you hit up the gym sans makeup and bypass the locker room without rinsing your skin when you're done, it's not the end of the world. Schultz points out that sweat contains urea, which is actually a moisturizing ingredient.

Image via Getty

What Actually Happened: I booked an evening barre class in the middle of the experiment. Earlier in the day I had applied a thin layer of a lightweight tinted moisturizer, a coat of mascara, a hint of blush and tinted lip balm. I generally don't sweat much during barre, so I wanted play it safe. I was also paranoid that people would stare at me if I looked too made-up, so I kept things relatively natural. Since I didn't get super-sweaty, my makeup was still intact at the end of the class. I dutifully slept in my makeup that night, and besides the few whiteheads that popped up during the course of the week, I didn't notice anything out of the ordinary the next morning.

Later in week, I hit up a morning Zumba class at my local gym sans makeup. I've never left a Zumba class without sopping in sweat, and this time was no different. To really ensure I wasn't washing my face, I hopped in my bath when I got home and rinsed off my body but didn't wash my hair (dry shampoo, FTW). I could've totally used a splash of cold water to cool down my face, which did look slightly flushed. This subsided after a few minutes, though, and I went about my makeup routine before going for a walk with my BF.

Image courtesy Christina Heiser

What an Expert Said Could Happen: On the last day of the experiment, I was ready to set myself up for major skin failure.

"Applying makeup over one day of makeup that has been caked into pores and has trapped dirt and free radicals could potentially cause a huge acne flare, cause significant irritation to the skin and eyes, and may takes weeks to recover from," says Marcbein.

Image via Getty

What Actually Happened: I forged ahead against dermatological advice (and my better judgment) and swiped on another coat of foundation (I chose one with SPF 15 so that I didn't feel too awful about not applying sunscreen in the morning), mascara, eye shadow and lip gloss on the last day of the experiment. Not only did my skin look crazy-shiny by midday, my foundation started to pill around my nose. What's more, my lashes felt really dry and my eyes started to itch. I had dinner plans with friends that night, so I decided to take off my makeup in my office bathroom before leaving work. I was officially done with the experiment and was excited about getting back to living my makeup-free life.

Image courtesy Christina Heiser