I have these in Pewter Pop (light gray with silver glitter) and Chocolate Pop (medium brown w/gold glitter).
PROS: Inexpensive. (got mine for $2 on sale)
CONS: Not long lasting. Poor pigmentation.
Overall, I'd pass on these and get some Jane or Wet n Wild gel/cream eyeliner if you're new to this...
by LipglossandSpandex | 521 reviews
9.0
UNIQUE AND EASY
I like these because they're unique and easy to use. They create a smudgy line that works great with a smokey eye (use a slanted eyeshadow brush). Another thing, they don't come off. No running, flaking, fading... The liner is there to stay. In my opinion, a great buy!
it worked really well at first, i used it with a slanted brush. it stayed put and didn't smudge much (since i had a smudging problem with many eye liners). but then i realized it dried out really quickly. it is still usable, but not as great as when i first got it.