This rates as "okay" for me. I thought I was purchasing a black, but it was really more of a pewter color which I ended up loving. I didn't mind too much because it was a pretty color and the product worked well. It wasn't super long-lasting but it lasted through-out a school day without...
This stuff is much like the mascara with the similar packaging. It has the most adorable packaging that makes you feel like a princess using it...however that does not make up for a shoddy product. I found this eyeliner to be very thin and watery. I had problems with it running all over my face.