I have No. 1 In Black and I really like it. The color is rich and pigmented and the texture is creamy and smooth. It does not tug on my lids, and stays all day on my waterline!
by aly7 | 396 reviews
8.0
GOOD PRODUCT, BUT...
I really like this liner. It's gentle on the waterline and lasts all day. My only reservation is that it only lasted about 2 months. I know that most makeup lasts way longer than it's good for you, but this seemed a bit extreme in the other direction. Nonetheless, I will buy it again.