I'm so surprised at all the negative reviews...
My experience with these is actually extremely positive.
I have the "Nude Eyes" trio, and use at least one of these every day...
I think that one of the reasons many people had bad experiences with these is that they see them and they think "NYX...
by Nikatron | 150 reviews
2.0
DISAPPOINTING
I usually love physician's formula products..but these were a dud. The eyeliners seem to work great as a swatch on my hand..but not so much on my eyes. They barely work. I wound up throwing mine away because I never used them so they really weren't worth keeping.
I loved the champagne shade in the set, but the packaging on these (while pretty) is awful. One broke at the base and I wasn't even being heavy-handed with it. And as other reviewers have pointed out, the cap is a pain in the rear. Might be better as a pencil form, like the Rimmel ones.