i used to wear pencil eyeliner all the time but got tired of the pulling and tugging across the eyelid, all for an uneven line that faded easily. i switched over to liquid eyeliner, which, after some practice to steady my hand, offered a bold impact but was also often uneven and flaked away...i...
by jenstar313 | 101 reviews
2.0
OILY SKIN BEWARE.
This ColorStay didn't stay at all. After 2 hours, it was smudging all over the place so I end up with an unintentional and unflattering smoky eye. Water also removes most of it on oilier complexions, so its waterproof promise is false. I like that it doesn't need sharpening, though. I guess it...
I will only rely on one eyeliner to stay put - and that is this one (thus far). I can put this on and not have to think about it again for about 6 hours, so it's perfect for evening. It doesn't take a miracle to take it off either, so that's an added plus. The disappointment lies in the...
by beautyguru_24_7 | 284 reviews
9.0
LOVE IT
I was not surprised to discover that this eye liner spreads easily and stays on well. the original shape of the tip does not last long, but if you angle it to the side, you can get a nice thin line. The brown is more like black though. I like all of the ColorStay line except the concealer.
by KelseaT | 171 reviews
8.0
GOOD PRODUCT!
This was slightly too green for my eyes, but the color was okay. Went on really smooth. Overall, I really like the eyeliner itself.
by mvap47 | 345 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts