This eye pencil is so soft and creamy -- which both works to its advantage and its detriment. On one hand: The blendability makes it perfect for creating a smoky eye. On the other: It's not great for precision, as it draws quite a thick line and it is very smudge-able.
by SlayZ | 600 reviews
8.0
GREAT FOR SMUDGING OUT AND THEN STAYING PUT
I feel like an eyeshadow averse person such as me can't quite utilize the versatility of this product. What I do know: you can completely manipulate this eyeliner for a few moments to smudge it out, and then the look locks into place and stays put all day. Do I feel quite comfortable wearing...
This thing stays on ALL DAY LONG! (without a primer) it's super creamy and so easy to apply and to smudge out. Pigmentation is great as well. My lids tend to get oily so I was very surprised that there was no smudging after wearing this for 9 hours in 80 degree weather!! it started to smudge a...
by piggysuperchi | 253 reviews
9.0
GO-TO WATERLINE EYELINER
HOLY PIGMENT. This eyeliner is thick, creamy and provides serious color. I wish I would've selected the black shade (as I got an off-white blueish color). The eyeliner holds up all day, including within the waterline -- which is seriously impressive. Great, quality eyeliner. Better be for that...
by jayla777 | 388 reviews
7.0
SMUDGY EYELINER
I got this in a red-pink, which I know is trending for eye makeup, but it might not be the best test for this one. However, I'll plow through: It's good if you want a very smokey look (I imagine, in black) or if you want to layer it on top of your black liner in a fun color. Very thick and...
by moonshadows | 205 reviews
GET FREE SAMPLES
sign up for our newsletter to get free sample alerts