Bourjois Effet Metallise

This highly metallic pencil liner is ultra creamy and glides on smooth. You can actually use it to line or fill in your entire lid -- it's that soft. The six colors are heavily pigmented, so you won't find yourself needing to apply multiple layers. It should really be a summertime or oily-skin "must-buy," as it stays put longer than most creamy liners do. That said, not everyone agrees that it's completely smudge-proof.