TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.7*
Why it's great: "This silky formula conditions lashes while you wear it," one reader writes. "It lengthens, adds volume and does not clump, flake or smudge." Other readers find that the product makes their lashes look "long, but not overdone."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.8*
Why it's great: "I've tried dozens of mascaras from cult fave drugstore brands to expensive, high-end formulas," says one reader. "This is the first and only one that truly is perfect for me." Other reviewers agree, saying, "This separates each lash to perfection" and "gives [lashes] length without an eyelash curler."
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.8*
Why it's great: Reviewers say this "incredible" product offers "amazing volume," "lasts all day without a touch-up" and "never flakes." One reader writes, "I love that this mascara never smudges, never runs and takes lashes to new lengths." Others love how easy it is to remove. "Just add warm water to remove, and it slides off your lashes in an instant," a reader writes.
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.8* Why it's great: This mascara gives you "lush, long, sexy, waterproof lashes," according to reviewers. One reviewer calls this "one of the best mascaras on the market." Another adds that it "goes on smooth without smudging."
"You can go swimming in the ocean all day and it will not come off," claims one reader about this mascara's waterproof powers.
TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 8.9*
Why it's great: "Easy on, easy off and no running," one reader sums up. Other reviewers love how thick and defined this product makes their lashes — without clumping. "This mascara is the best one for allergies," adds another reader. "It doesn't burn ... I love this product."
We all want long, lush lashes that make our eyes pop, but only the best mascaras can get the job done. We're talking those holy grail mascaras with wands that grab and coat every last lash, formulas that let you layer without clumps and give you the volume, length and definition you crave — all day long, without smudging. Is that really so much to ask?
Our readers didn't think so, either, which is why they tested out mascara after mascara to come up with the definitive ranking of the best mascaras. The list includes the latest and greatest clump-free formulas with genius, futuristic-looking wands as well as tried-and-true classics. Whether you're looking for length, volume, curl (or all of the above), we've got the perfect mascara for you and your lashes. Drum roll, please.
