"The right makeup is key to making a new hair color look natural," says Turnbow, who used tones from Jennifer's bold hair and her eye color -- golden-orange eye shadow (try Bare Escentuals i.d. bareMinerals Eye Shadow in Citrus Twist, $12) and a shimmery peach blush (try Nars Blush in Deep Throat, $25). She finishes the look with a universally flattering pinky-peach gloss (see our favorite glosses here).

"I should've been born with this hair color!" Jennifer says, adding that her new look has inspired her to spend more time on herself, find new ways to style her hair (curly and straight), and play with makeup at the cosmetics counter.