To cover up the eyebrow accident, use powder, a fine pencil or even a brow pen to fill in any gaps. First, create an outline to create the shape that you want. Then, draw hair-like strokes on the over-plucked areas. Make sure to keep it natural-looking so it won't be too obvious that you're hiding something. Finish with an eyebrow gel so it won't fade as you go through your day. We recommend a brow kit like the Glossier Brow Flick + Boy Brow Duo, $30, for an extra natural look.